I grew up a Presbyterian, back in the day when it was the Rolls Royce of Protestant denominations.
Presbyterians, in the form of the Church of Scotland/Presbyterian Church of New Zealand, had the best boarding and day schools -- almost a military operation of their own -- rigorous academics, high moral standards, the lot.
When my parents divorced, a Scottish Presbyterian minister pointed out that there'd have been some reason for it somewhere, and all you could do was go on living your own life, and see where it led you.
He also pointed out that you couldn't see God, just the effects of God, in the same way that you cannot actually see electricity, just its effects.
It was a fair enough argument for a doubting pre-teen. It came from a man with no fingernails, who'd run a seaman's mission in unoccupied France during the second world war and had been picked up one or two times by the Gestapo for running an escape line for allied air crew.
Once out of the Presbyterian Private School Environment, university, and then out travelling the world and shooting images of it, writing about it, looking at it, I got a bit slack when it came to attending church services of any sort.
I moved into the world occupied by most people, especially in New Zealand and Australia and Britain and Western Europe, and including now in their number a former minister of mine in New Zealand, Rinnie Westra. I became a cultural Christian, a social Christian.
Which means you generally back the overall policies, try to live a fairly decent life, hold a few solid principals, go to a church, no real matter which, on Easter and Christmas.You're not gungho, you're just lower case, going for the communal aspect rather than from any rigidly held set of beliefs. I'm willing to accept the idea of a God, just not perhaps all the trappings and ceremonies.
That was about it.
Every so often I'd get a bit more serious, but the thing I liked about being a Presbyterian was the fact that it had encouraged, all my life, your own deep level of personal examination of faith, and there I was doing it: I might not have been a good Presbyterian in attending terms, but I was a solid Presbyterian in terms of thought. That's what we'd been encouraged to do during all those years of youthful study.
I traveled the world. I met Hindus and Buddhists and Muslims, Animists and Deists, the full range of beliefs. Give, get. You tolerate other peoples' beliefs on equal terms as yours, and they'll mostly do the same with yours -- it's a fairly simple philosophy.
There were cases when people really put their lives on the line for mine. They were not Presbyterian, or even Christian. However: this point I will come back to.
Since I settled in America, I resumed for the most part attendance at Presbyterian services. I moved into positions of elder, deacon, clerk of session, roles I'm told one of my grandparents also served in the the Presbyterian church in New Zealand. There were some parts of the country where Presbyterians were thin on the ground -- very few in Idaho, not many in Vermont, either.
The leadership in the local churches are not from the same source as I am: they're well-schooled in theology, moved from Catholicism or Anglicanism for various reasons, accepted Presbyterianism later in life. Generally, quite cold: you wouldn't expect to see them running a seaman's mission, living on pennies, losing their fingernails to a Gestapo interrogator.
Nor so accepting of the flexibility of thought that marked my early Presbyterian education.
I heard a minister, originally from the South, announce during a sermon that only the accepting Christian would ever make it to heaven. And something in me stopped for a moment.
Assuming that there is in fact a heaven, assuming in fact that there is a God, assuming that he did indeed as claimed create us all, then he also created all the ideas within us, and that'd include ways of faith.
As a Catholic priest said to me once in a rattley old Renault 5 barrelling around the island of Barra in the outer Hebrides of Scotland when he discovered that unlike most of the islanders, I was a Presby rather than a good Cat: different road, same destination.
I've met a hell of a lot of kind people who were neither Christian nor Presbyterian: who are we, or anyone else, to say who gets into Heaven or not?
Once you get involved in the day to day running of a church, it's a bit like seeing how something is made: it loses its magic, to an extent.
You see the inner squabbles and snarks, the lack of involvement, the disinterest. For the local Catholic church, the decline has meant the consolidation of parishes all over the diocese, and that's gone down like a lead balloon among the reduced numbers of the faithful. Their reduced numbers, and the shortage of both priests and money, has underlined the need for reductions.
Our local Presbyterian church is the result of a recent, unsteady, merger of three who barely managed a half a hundred active members. Once joined, the minister who oversaw the merger called it quits and headed back to the safety of the South, where Presbyterianism is more the flavor of Billy Graham than William Sloane Coffin.
I can recognise the religious approach of the late Reverend Coffin, who ran a big liberal New York church: I can't understand the religious fanatism, the hatred and viciousness that comes through in the practises of the Graham family.
That's not the Presbyterianism I grew up with, it's not the Presbyterianism I'm comfortable with, it's probably not the Presbyterianism I'll be staying with.
And if that's the only Presbyterianism that's available to me, then I'll be moving off in the direction of Buddhist study.
I might not know what the future is, but at least I'll be at peace with it.
No comments:
Post a Comment