Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Recycling For Profit

So, Wednesday morning.

 The recycling has gone, collected by the city and carted off in the trash truck.

 Recycling has gotten bigger over the years: when they first started collections, there were so many limits that inactivity ruled: people couldn't be bothered sorting and washing and counting the numbers.

 Pie tins yes, or pie tins no?

 So it went, the federal government giving enough money to keep the program alive at the doorstep, and enough people sorting and separating their cans, numbered plastics, newspapers without the inserts.

 Years passed. The collections broadened.

 And the city discovered something to its advantage. Even with medium to light recycling, at $55 a ton for trash, the savings over a month were pretty significant.

 Fast forward a decade or so, and the new system of throwing everything in a single bin, no sorting, has sped things up for the city. The single stream collection still saves the city the cost of dumping, and someone else gets paid to actually sort the whole load, and turn whatever profit they can.

 The situation in many ways is not unlike that of the Bangladeshi boat dismantlers, who generate what they can in dodgy circumstances, at significant risk to themselves, with welding torches and cutters. Made for great photographs, but that's a hell of a price people have to pay, especially for an image.

 We tend to forget that people are living lives in those iconic images that turned up in Life Magazine. The Migrant Mother didn't exactly love the image of her that Dorothea Lange created of her.

 One hopes that the workers who're sorting out our crap are looked after a bit better than the Bangladeshi boat breakers, but I'd tend not to believe it. I've worked a few jobs in America where I could have been a machine: the only reason me and the dozens of others were doing the work was that we were cheaper than the machine  that could have done the job.

 And anywhere in Europe, would have been doing it.

 There was a recent International Labour Union study that showed of all the major developed nations, the United States was one of the crappier ones when it came to worker rights.

 There's a strike going on by Walmart workers: they're lucky to make $15,000 a year, and we as taxpayers subsidize their heathcare costs, while the head of Walmart makes $15,000 an hour.

 Hard to tell whether he deserves that sort of income, considering that the chain hasn't seen growth in the last year or so. Equally hard when Costco, which pays staff well, has seen nothing but increased sales, bad winter or no bad winter.

 The recycling workers might have a bigger problem than just miserable working conditions, at least as far as America is concerned.

 There's no mandate to use recycled materials, and we just live in the hope that manufacturers will use recycled materials because its in their best Public Relations interests. But there have been times when the recycled materials have just sat around, without a sale to China or Malaysia or India, because the markets there haven't needed the cheaper cost material recycling provides.

 So the stuff that goes out on Wednesday just sits in a warehouse somewhere, waiting for someone to want 200,000 tons of used tin, or mulched paper product in bales.

 It'd be nice to live in a world where every manufactured item was created from the previously used, and packaging was negligible, at best.

 But in this country, where capital dictates the market, rather than, at this stage, the consumer, that's not going to happen without a major change in political will.
And the political will won't be there until the way US politics is run is also changed, because the same companies that produce the crap that I have to recycle own the politicians that would have to vote to compel companies to take their junk back.

  It happens in other countries: the Germans have been doing it for years. But their politicians are a little less owned by corporate interests than ours are.

No comments:

Post a Comment